6005-T5 or 6061-T6 for an EV battery tray: where each alloy wins, the four failure modes alloy choice does not fix, and the eight lines to put on the drawing.
6005-T5 or 6061-T6: Choosing the Alloy for an EV Battery Tray
When a battery tray drawing arrives, the first question is rarely about the extrusion profile. It is about the alloy. Two grades come up in almost every electric-vehicle enclosure enquiry we receive: 6005-T5 and 6061-T6. Both are heat-treatable 6xxx alloys. Both extrude well. Both are stocked in China. The differences only start to matter once you look at the whole tray — crash structure, seals, fasteners and the cost of the billet.
This note explains what each alloy is actually good at, where buyers get caught, and what to put on the drawing so the quote you receive is comparable.
The short answer
| Requirement | Better fit | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Long, thin-walled side rails and cross members | 6005-T5 | Higher extrusion speed and better surface on thin walls; T5 is enough for stiffness-driven parts |
| Machined mounting bosses, tapped holes, structural corners | 6061-T6 | Higher strength after full T6 aging; machines cleanly and holds threads well |
| Mixed profile + heavy machining | 6061-T6 | One alloy for the whole assembly simplifies traceability |
| Cost-sensitive, high-volume, low-stress frame | 6005-T5 | Cheaper per kilo at the same section, faster press time |
| Parts that must be welded after extrusion | 6005-T5 (check filler) | 6005 welds acceptably; 6061 loses strength in the heat-affected zone |
A tray is usually both: a stiffness-driven frame plus a handful of load-bearing machined parts. Splitting the bill of materials between the two alloys is normal — and it is usually cheaper than forcing everything into 6061-T6.
Where 6005-T5 wins
6005 is a 6xxx alloy with a tighter chemistry window than 6063 and higher silicon. In practice that gives three things on a tray:
- Thin walls extrude more reliably. Sections in the 1.5–2.5 mm range hold tolerance better than 6061, which is stiffer in the die and more prone to surface tearing at high speed.
- Better as-extruded surface. If the tray side rail is visible after assembly, 6005 needs less rework before anodizing or powder coating.
- Faster press time, lower price. On a 660 t to 1800 t press, 6005 runs noticeably faster than 6061 at the same section, and the billet is cheaper.
The trade-off is strength. 6005-T5 typically sits around 270 MPa ultimate tensile strength, against roughly 310 MPa for 6061-T6. For a component sized by stiffness (deflection under a defined load) that difference rarely changes the section. For a component sized by yield — a bracket carrying a heavy module, a tapped boss taking bolt preload — it does.
Where 6061-T6 wins
6061 is the alloy most automotive and industrial buyers already have in their drawing library. On a battery tray it earns its place in four situations:
- Machined interfaces. Motor mounts, busbar brackets and cooling-plate manifolds need tight tolerances and thread strength. 6061-T6 machines faster, holds a tapped M6 thread better, and does not smear.
- Structural corners. Where the tray frame is bolted rather than welded, higher yield strength lets you keep the corner block small.
- Single-alloy traceability. One heat number, one set of mechanical certificates, one alloy in the weld procedure.
- Post-weld strength recovery. If a T6 part must be welded, you can re-age it; 6005-T5 parts are usually not re-aged.
The costs are real: 6061 extrudes slower, is less forgiving on thin walls, and typically carries a higher billet price. On a large frame made of long thin rails, those three costs add up quickly.
What actually fails on a battery tray
Alloy choice is only one line on the drawing. In our experience with enclosure work, the failure modes that come back from the field are rarely "the alloy was wrong". They are:
- Sealing around the flange. A tray with a 1.8 mm flange face and no flatness callout will leak at IP67 regardless of alloy. Specify flatness per 100 mm on the sealing face, not just profile tolerance.
- Galvanic corrosion at steel fasteners. Aluminum plus a bare steel bolt plus road salt is a corrosion cell. Specify plated fasteners, isolating washers or a conversion coating on the tray.
- Heat-affected zone cracking after welding. If the tray is welded after extrusion, the temper in the HAZ drops. Either design for it or use friction-stir or structural adhesive.
- Dimensional drift after powder coating. Cure oven temperatures can move a long rail out of tolerance if the part was straightened before coating. Straighten after coating, or bake-stabilize first.
None of these are fixed by switching from 6005 to 6061. They are fixed on the drawing.
What to put on the drawing
If you want quotes you can compare, put these eight items on the RFQ:
| Item | Example |
|---|---|
| Alloy and temper, per part | 6005-T5 for rails, 6061-T6 for brackets |
| Governing standard | EN 573-3 / EN 755-2, or ASTM B221 |
| Profile tolerance | EN 755-9, or your own flatness/straightness callout |
| Critical machined features | Datum scheme, thread class, position tolerance |
| Sealing face flatness | e.g. 0.2 mm per 100 mm, measured dry |
| Surface treatment | Powder coat RAL code, target film thickness in microns |
| Test requirement | Helium leak, water immersion, or air decay — and the acceptance limit |
| Documentation | Mill certificate per heat, dimensional report, PPAP level if automotive |
Two extra lines that save weeks: state whether the tray is welded or bonded, and state the annual and monthly volume. Press time and die cost are quoted against volume; without it, every supplier guesses differently.
How we approach it
SYHARVEST extrudes 6063, 6061 and 6005 on eight presses from 660 t to 3600/4000 t, then machines on 20+ CNC centers and finishes with vertical powder coating, horizontal anodizing or optional electrophoresis. For enclosure work the usual split is 6005-T5 for long rails and 6061-T6 for machined interfaces, with both alloys coming off the same line and sharing one dimensional report.
If you are comparing alloys for a tray, send the drawing with the eight items above and we will quote both options side by side: same section, two alloys, two prices, so the trade-off is visible rather than argued.
For the wider requirement set on enclosures — ingress protection, thermal paths, module mounting — see our earlier note on aluminum extrusion for EV battery enclosures. You can also review the full product range before sending a drawing.
Interested in Our Products?
Contact us today for a professional quotation tailored to your requirements.
Get a Free Quote